Offensive Rookie of the Year: It’s Mayfield vs. Barkley, But Let’s Not Forget These Three

Could Lindsay, Chubb or Michel push into the OROY debate?

Saquon Barkley appeared ready to run away with the 2018 offensive rookie of the year award—until Baker Mayfield's recent surge following Hue Jackson's departure from Cleveland. Barkley has been consistently great all year, but Mayfield has sparked a turnaround of the downtrodden Browns—with three games left in the season, the team that went 0-16 last year still has a not-unrealistic shot at the AFC North title. The Giants running back and Browns quarterback are clearly the top two candidates, so let’s take a look at the next-best offensive rookies, a trio of running backs who have broken onto the scene this season. 

Phillip Lindsay, Denver
The undrafted rookie wasn't even sure he'd make Denver's roster and is now the Broncos’ leading rusher, and on track to surpass 1,000 yards. He's got 967 yards and nine touchdowns on the season with three games left to play. Lindsay is the only player this decade to average at least 7.0 yards per carry in three consecutive games, he leads the league with 5.8 yards per carry and he has yet to fumble. 

Nick Chubb, Cleveland 
Mayfield gets all the credit for Cleveland's improvement this season, but Chubb's contributions to the turnaround should not be overlooked. The second-rounder has a 92-yard touchdown run this year, the longest in Browns history. His touchdown against the Falcons on Sunday put him in special company—he became the first Browns player since Greg Pruitt in 1975 with a rushing touchdown in five straight games. Only two Browns backs have ever had longer streaks: Hall of Famers Leroy Kelly and Jim Brown. And Chubb is one of just two running backs in the league averaging more than four yards after contact.

Sony Michel, New England 
New England's first-round pick has become the lead back, and carries the Patriots run game. The Georgia product has three 100-yard rushing performances this season and is a reliable rookie cog in New England's offense.

It will take something truly special for any of these three to break into the Mayfield-Barkley debate, but it’s worth acknowledging that those two aren’t the only NFL rookies making an impact on offense in 2018. 

Not getting this newsletter in your inbox yet?Sign up for The MMQB’s Morning Huddle.

HOT READS

NOW ON THE MMQB: Conor Orr on the Seahawks’ dominant win over Minnesota, and the emergence of an elite defense ... Albert Breer's MMQB on the Miami Miracle, the Bears defense, and more ... Breer on what the Raiders will look for in their next general manager, after firing Reggie McKenzie on Monday ... There are 32 starting quarterbacks, and Josh Johnson is one of them. 

WHAT YOU MIGHT HAVE MISSED: Andy Benoit on Phillip Rivers’ career year ... How Amari Cooper has saved the Cowboys' season ... the coaching hot seat after Week 14.

PRESS COVERAGE

1. Jason Witten denied ESPN's report about a potential return to the Cowboys.

2. Vance Joseph doesn't want Von Miller to guess the snap count.

3. Bill Belichick elaborates further on why Rob Gronkowski was on the field for the last play.

4. Kenyan Drake politely requests the return of his TD ball.

5. Yes, Bobby Wagner’s field goal block against the Vikings amounted to illegal leverage. Here’s how to do it right.

THE KICKER

Bill Belichick on the Pats loss to Miami: “It's the national football league. Nobody died.”

Question? Comment? Story idea? Let the team know at talkback@themmqb.com.